The recent admission by Liberia's Deputy Minister of Information, Daniel O. Sando, regarding substantial gifts received by the Ministry has indeed thrust the issue of public sector gift-giving into the spotlight, revealing a profoundly concerning trend in Liberian governance. This incident, along with similar cases across multiple government agencies, draws attention to a growing crisis that threatens the institutional integrity of Liberia's public institutions and the rule of law.
Daniel O. Sando, the Deputy Minister for Press and Public Affairs at the Ministry of Information, Culture Affairs, and Tourism (MICAT), has been prominent in Liberian politics and social advocacy[8]. His recent statement that MICAT raised US$47,000 from private sector actors and some government agencies has sparked controversy and raised questions about the ethical standards within government institutions.
This revelation comes at a time when the Boakai administration, which took office on January 22, 2024, with promises to "rescue" Liberia from corrupt practices, appears to be falling short of its good governance priorities[7]. The administration's commitment to transparency and accountability is being tested as reports of questionable practices continue to emerge across various sectors of the government.
The issue of gift-giving in Liberia's public sector is not isolated to a single ministry. Similar incidents have been reported across various government agencies, including the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, where Former Commerce Minister Amin Modad was accused of accepting a luxury vehicle worth US$96,000 as a "gift" from a company alleged to have defrauded the Liberian people[7]. These practices directly contravene Liberia's Code of Conduct for Public Officials and Employees of Government, which explicitly prohibits public officials from receiving or encouraging "any form of bribe or casual gift in connection with the performance of his or her official duties"[7].
The prevalence of such gift-giving raises serious questions about the enforcement of existing anti-corruption laws and the commitment of public officials to ethical governance. It also highlights the challenges faced by the Boakai administration in fulfilling its campaign promises to combat corruption and promote transparency in government operations[6].
As Liberia grapples with these issues, the need for comprehensive reforms and strengthened accountability measures becomes increasingly apparent. The government's actions in response to these revelations will be crucial in determining the future trajectory of Liberia's journey towards good governance and the rule of law.
The Scope of the Problem
The scope of gift-giving practices in Liberia's public sector extends beyond a single ministry, revealing a concerning pattern across various government agencies. This trend raises significant questions about Liberian governance's ethical standards and transparency.
At the Ministry of Information, Cultural Affairs, and Tourism (MICAT), Deputy Minister Daniel O. Sando confirmed that Minister Jerolimek Matthew Piah raised over $47,000 from Jetty and other entities for renovations at the ministry[5]. This admission came amid allegations of financial misconduct within MICAT, including claims of cash distributions to staff members coinciding with major government events[5].
In the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, former Minister Amin Modad also faced similar accusations of receiving a gift from MedTech Scientific Limited to purchase a vehicle valued at US$96,000[4]. The controversy highlighted the complex relationship between government officials and private businesses. The Liberia Revenue Authority (LRA) confirmed approving the Ministry of Commerce's request for US$96,000 from its Customs Capacity Building Fund for vehicle purchases, further complicating the narrative[4].
In addition, Minister Roland Giddings acknowledged widespread corruption within the sector at the Ministry of Public Works, which led to stalled developmental projects and significant financial losses for the government[7]. Conversely, he admitted to receiving cars as contractors' gifts, contradicting his statement on his willingness to fight corruption [7].
The Ministry of Labor has also been implicated in questionable practices. There have been reports of Concession Companies offering gifts to senior officials, thereby influencing decisions. These incidents collectively paint a picture of a public sector grappling with ethical challenges and potential conflicts of interest. The prevalence of such practices across multiple ministries underscores the need for comprehensive reforms to enhance transparency, accountability, and adherence to ethical standards in Liberian governance.
Legal and Ethical Implications
The legal and ethical implications of gift-giving and bribery in Liberia's public sector are significant and far-reaching, as these practices directly contravene established laws and codes of conduct. The primary legal frameworks addressing this issue are the Code of Conduct for Public Officials and Employees of Government and the Penal Law of Liberia.
Section 9.1 of the Code of Conduct explicitly states:
"Public Officials and Employees of Government shall not receive nor encourage the giving of any form of bribe or casual gift in connection with the performance of his or her official duties, whether for himself or herself or members of his or her family or any other benefits that could have any influence on his or her professional approach to issues and the discharge of his or her official duties"[5].
This provision is designed to maintain the integrity of public service by preventing officials from being influenced by external parties through gifts or bribes. The Code further elaborates on the handling of gifts in subsequent sections:
1. Section 9.2 requires that any token gift received must be declared to the appropriate authority within seven days, which will decide whether the official may retain it or surrender it to the government[5].
2. Section 9.4 mandates that public officials report any offers of gifts or benefits, especially if they feel these were attempts to influence their official actions or decisions[5].
3. Section 9.5 addresses gifts from foreign governments or international organizations, requiring prompt declaration and potential surrender to the government[5].
Beyond the Code of Conduct, the Penal Law of Liberia provides criminal penalties for bribery. Section 12.50 of the Penal Law classifies bribery as a second-degree felony[4]. This classification carries significant legal consequences, as explained by Cllr. Tiawan Saye Gongloe:
"The law unequivocally prohibits any public servant from receiving, soliciting, or accepting bribes in exchange for official actions or neglecting their duties"[4].
Bribery is a second-degree felony punishable by up to five years of imprisonment[4]. This severe penalty underscores the gravity with which Liberian law views corruption in public office.
The legal framework extends beyond just the recipients of bribes. Under Liberian law, both the givers and receivers of bribes can be held accountable.
These legal provisions reflect the ethical principle that public service should be conducted with integrity and in the public's interest, not for personal gain. Accepting gifts or bribes undermines this principle and erodes public trust in government institutions.
The legal and ethical implications of gift-giving and bribery in Liberia's public sector are severe. These practices not only violate specific laws and codes of conduct but also undermine the fundamental principles of good governance and public trust. The challenge lies in enforcing these laws consistently and creating a culture of integrity within Liberia's public institutions.
Systemic Failures and Consequences
The prevalence of gift-giving in Liberian public service points to several systemic failures:
1. Weak enforcement of existing laws and regulations.
2. Inadequate funding of public institutions creates a perceived need for external "support."
3. A cultural tolerance for practices that blur the lines between gifts and bribes.
These failures have far-reaching consequences. Liberia's ranking on the Transparency International Corruption Perception Index remains low, scoring just 25 out of 100 points and ranking 145th out of 180 countries in 2023[14]. This perception of widespread corruption hampers economic development, deters investment, and undermines public confidence in state institutions.
The U.S. Department of State's 2024 Investment Climate Statements cite corruption as the primary reason few investors come to Liberia, jobs are not being created, and instability is a risk[5]. The report states, "Liberia suffers from corruption in both the public and private sectors, which is widely viewed as the primary reason Liberia's democracy and economy are not strengthening"[5].
The Way Forward
Addressing this crisis requires a multi-faceted approach:
1. Strengthen oversight and accountability mechanisms, particularly the Liberia Anti-Corruption Commission (LACC)[6].
2. Implement a zero-tolerance policy on gift-giving to public officials.
3. Increase budgetary allocations to public institutions to eliminate the perceived need for external contributions.
4. Launch public awareness campaigns to educate citizens on the dangers of normalized corruption[7].
5. Enforce strict penalties for violations, including dismissal from office and criminal prosecution[9].
Conclusion
The normalization of gift-giving to public officials in Liberia represents a clear and present danger to good governance and the rule of law. As the country grapples with this crisis, it is imperative that all stakeholders – government officials, civil society, and citizens – work together to restore integrity to public service.
Implementing institutional reforms, such as strengthening accountability mechanisms and increasing transparency in decision-making processes, could help combat corruption and promote good governance[6]. Only through concerted effort and unwavering commitment to ethical governance can Liberia hope to build a more transparent, accountable, and prosperous future for all its citizens.
As the country continues to struggle with corruption and governance challenges, it is clear that addressing these issues is fundamental to Liberia's economic development and political stability[4][5]. The fight against corruption must be prioritized to ensure a brighter future for Liberia and its people.
_______________________________________________________________________________
Get Involved
Do you have additional facts to add to this insight or an opinion you would like to express?
Email Us
References:
[1] https://www.micat.gov.lr
[2] https://faolex.fao.org/docs/pdf/lbr202653.pdf
[3] https://frontpageafricaonline.com/politics/shattered-2017-quest-ripple-effect-of-code-of-conduct-ruling-on-potential-contenders/
[4] https://cental.org.lr/index.php/documents/media-center/news/item/132-liberia-declines-in-transparency-international-s-corruption-perception-index-2023Crisis of Gift-Giving, Liberia's Public Sector, Threat to Rule of Law
[5] https://thenewdawnliberia.com/liberia-corruption-scares-away-investors/
[6] https://lacc.gov.lr/sites/default/files/documents/LACC-Stragety-Plan.pdf
[7] https://www.undp.org/liberia/press-releases/lacc-undp-host-anti-corruption-training-strengthen-integrity-and-accountabilityCrisis of Gift-Giving, Liberia's Public Sector, Threat to Rule of LawCrisis of Gift-Giving, Liberia's Public Sector, Threat to Rule of Law
[8] https://www.micat.gov.lr/senior-management/deputy-minister-press-and-public-affairs
[9] https://allafrica.com/stories/202410210288.html
[10] https://africlaw.com/2018/08/02/freedom-of-expression-hopes-anxieties-and-skepticism-in-liberias-nascent-democracyCrisis of Gift-Giving, Liberia's Public Sector, Threat to Rule of LawCrisis of Gift-Giving, Liberia's Public Sector, Threat to Rule of Law/
[11] https://frontpageafricaonline.com/news/liberia-only-west-african-country-to-drop-seven-points-in-corruption-perception-index/Crisis of Gift-Giving, Liberia's Public Sector, Threat to Rule of LawCrisis of Gift-Giving, Liberia's Public Sector, Threat to Rule of Law
[12] https://lacc.gov.lr
[13] https://www.undp.org/liberia/press-releases/lacc-conducts-anti-corruption-training
[14] https://tradingeconomics.com/liberia/corruption-index
[1] https://ppl-ai-file-upload.s3.amazonaws.com/web/direct-files/40974682/1f1c8fc1-1bab-4265-a15b-cf0ebdb3e479/paste.txt
[2] https://ppl-ai-file-upload.s3.amazonaws.com/web/direct-files/40974682/ef4a8109-f1bc-4041-8f22-afc96d7c2a04/paste-2.txt
[3] https://inprofiledailynews.com/micat-officials-calls-on-cdc-to-peacefully-vacate-private-property/
[4] https://oraclenewsdaily.com/2024/09/26/liberia-%F0%9D%97%95%F0%9D%98%82%F0%9D%97%B1%F0%9D%97%B4%F0%9D%97%B2%F0%9D%98%81-%F0%9D%97%99%F0%9D%97%B6%F0%9D%97%AE%F0%9D%98%80%F0%9D%97%B0%F0%9D%97%BC%F0%9D%98%80-%F0%9D%97%96%F0%9D%97%BC/
[5] https://www.usaid.gov/sites/default/files/2022-05/CDCS_Liberia_June_2024.pdf
[6] https://www.micat.gov.lr/media/lina-daily-news-bulletin/min-sando-assures-liberians-greater-impact-boakais-govt
[7] https://frontpageafricaonline.com/politics/liberia-disenchanted-ruling-partys-partisans-question-civil-service-agency-over-liberias-rising-wage-bill/
Comments